Etude House Color My Brows-Brow Mascara

I have super thin almost transparent eyebrow. So, for me, eyebrow penci, shadow or anythin than can color mine is a must. I've been religiously using Skinfood Eyebrw Shadow, beside it's super cheap price, the color suit me most, and the brush is okay. It's my five minutes to go touch up stuff.
On my last holiday, I lost it, can you believe, when you in the middle of no where you lost your must have? As soon as I came back to the city, I went to the nearest mall, but I couldn't find any Skinfood counter, then I went to Etude House, and their SA offered me an eyebrow mascara, he said it'll come more naturally then the shadow. Ha! what can be more natural than the shadow. That's when I decided to purchase it.
First time I'm using it it became disaster, my eyebrow became super thick and I look wether fierce or devilish not in a good way. But one's said practice makes perfect, so i gave it a try, on day three I became a whiz. Now you can see it below pictures,

Do I already look like Lilly Collins or still devilish?

Etude House Color My Brow in rich dark brown